IMF on Banks' Profitability
In Europe profits are not here to stay
European banks experienced a surge in profitability in 2023, driven primarily by rapidly rising interest margins. An IMF Report provides an in-depth analysis of these trends and examines the sustainability of this profitability surge. The findings suggest that European banks are currently benefiting from cyclical factors rather than any significant long-term improvement in their operational or structural efficiency.
The key factor driving the sharp rise in bank profits in 2023 was the widening of net interest margins (NIMs). As central banks increased policy rates, European banks responded by increasing lending rates faster than deposit rates. This slower pass-through of higher interest rates to deposits enabled banks to capitalize on the difference between what they earned from loans and what they paid for deposits.
Additionally, banks' asset quality remained resilient throughout the period, keeping impairment costs low, which further boosted profitability. This is a significant departure from the low profitability that has characterized European banks since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), where low interest rates and poor operational efficiency hindered bank performance.
Sustainability Concerns
Despite this temporary boom, the report cautions that European banks' high profits are unlikely to persist. Several factors suggest that this profitability will fade:
Interest Rate Normalization: As central banks begin to lower policy rates in the future, the benefit of higher NIMs will diminish. Historically, as rates decline, deposit rates tend to remain sticky, causing interest margins to shrink.
Rising Credit Risks: Higher borrowing costs are expected to increase the risk of non-performing loans (NPLs), particularly as economic conditions tighten. This will likely increase impairment costs, putting pressure on bank earnings.
Structural Issues Remain: European banks still face several structural challenges that have plagued the sector for years, including overcapacity, low operational cost efficiency, and slow adoption of digital technologies. These factors have not been sufficiently addressed and will continue to drag on long-term profitability once the current cyclical factors fade.
Policy Implications
The report advises policymakers to tread cautiously when considering interventions such as windfall taxes or other measures targeting bank profits. While these measures could generate public funds, they could also reduce banks' ability to build capital buffers, which are crucial for absorbing future shocks.
Long-Term Outlook
In the long run, European banks need to address structural inefficiencies to ensure sustained profitability. This includes improving cost efficiency, adopting more advanced technologies, and consolidating to address market overcapacity. Without these reforms, the profitability boost seen in 2023 will be a short-lived phenomenon, and European banks will struggle to compete with their counterparts in other regions, such as the United States and Canada, which have shown stronger recovery and profitability since the GFC.
Conclusion
While European banks have enjoyed a temporary boost in profitability, the report concludes that these profits are unlikely to be sustained in the face of declining interest margins and rising credit risks. For European banks to ensure long-term financial health, a focus on addressing structural inefficiencies and building resilience to future economic shocks is critical.
Entering Italian NPE Market is a newsletter and a Linkedin Group focused on News, Updates and Insights on Italian Banks, Ditressed Credit Market, Fintech and Real Estate.
Relevant Links:
https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2024/07/09/Bank-Profitability-in-Europe-Not-Here-to-Stay-551129
This newsletter is free please consider supporting it with a small donation
See my full professional profile (available for consulting projects)
My Podcast on Financial News and Education
My new Podcast on Italian Politics