Accuria Report on NPL Directive

Implementation inconsistent, with significant regulatory fragmentation persisting

The EU introduced Directive 2021/2167 to foster a robust, harmonized secondary market for NPLs. Its goals include reducing banks’ bad debt burdens, encouraging cross-border transactions, and standardizing servicer regulation. Yet, its rollout has been staggered: countries like Germany and France met deadlines, while others, including Spain and Portugal, lagged behind. National legal nuances, gold-plated additions, and fragmented judicial systems further dilute the intended harmonization.

Licensing and Compliance Complexities
At the heart of the directive is the mandate for credit servicers to obtain licenses and meet detailed compliance requirements. These include business plan submissions, governance checks, and risk control standards. In jurisdictions like Germany, application processes run hundreds of pages, and annual compliance costs can top €300,000. While large, tech-savvy servicers can absorb these costs, smaller firms struggle, leading to market exits or consolidation.

The Myth of a Level Playing Field
Although a European passport for servicers theoretically allows cross-border operations without re-licensing, national deviations persist. For example, Greece mandates borrower portals; Spain’s proposed rules add consumer protections beyond the directive’s scope. These variations create compliance headaches and increase operational costs for cross-border actors.

Market Consolidation and Smaller Servicer Strain
Rising regulatory demands and fixed compliance costs are driving consolidation. Larger servicers like doValue and Intrum, armed with capital and compliance infrastructure, are acquiring smaller competitors. Meanwhile, niche firms either specialize in asset classes/geographies or exit entirely. This trend threatens liquidity in the market for small NPL portfolios, making such trades less attractive and potentially keeping NPLs stuck on bank balance sheets.

Entering Italian NPE Market is a Newsletter and a Linkedin Group focused on News, Updates, and Insights on Italian Banks, Distressed Credit Markets, Fintech, and Real Estate.

Operational and Technological Shifts
The directive pushes servicers toward digital transformation. AI tools, data transparency systems, and compliance tech are becoming non-negotiable. Yet, smaller servicers often lack the resources for such upgrades. Additionally, the evolving landscape demands servicers pivot toward sub-performing loans (SPLs), requiring borrower-centric strategies and early intervention capabilities.

EBA Data Templates: Standardization vs. Reality
The EBA’s standardized NPL transaction templates are designed to improve transparency. While useful in principle, many banks—especially smaller ones—struggle to meet the requirements due to legacy systems and data gaps. Some still proceed with partial data without penalties, suggesting that enforcement remains flexible and adoption uneven.

Conclusion
The NPL Directive marks a significant step toward professionalizing the European credit servicing market. However, its effectiveness is undermined by fragmented national implementations, disproportionate compliance costs for smaller firms, and delayed adoption. Instead of a harmonized marketplace, the EU now has a patchwork of regimes layered on top of shared rules. The winners are large servicers with the resources to scale and adapt; the losers are smaller players squeezed by regulatory costs and complexity.

For the directive to achieve its promise, EU institutions must monitor national deviations, support smaller servicers with clearer guidance and proportional compliance, and ensure that cross-border transaction barriers are meaningfully lowered. Until then, the vision of a seamless EU-wide NPL market remains out of reach.

Relevant Links:

https://accuria.com/cross-country-deep-dive-on-the-implementation-of-the-eu-npl-directive/

This newsletter is free please consider supporting it with a small donation

See my full professional profile (available for consulting projects)

My Podcast on Financial News and Education

My new Podcast on Italian Politics